Monday, October 20, 2008
Posted by Jon Westfall in "Pocket PC Hardware" @ 09:00 AM
SCOTTEVEST has been careful not to call this the direct update to the 4.0 line because some of the 4.0 series nuances are missing in the 5.0 Signature series. For example, on the jacket, a front right breast pocket with ID card window has been removed. The new version in the 5.0 line is a internal lower-left pouch specifically to hold your ID and provide quick access. Yet you can't be wearing your ID here and have others see it, a potential problem for those of us who must wear visible ID.
Here are some other quick differences I've observed:
- The hood on the jacket, while still removable, does not roll up and tuck away like previous versions.
- The sleeves on the jacket are not removable. Scott Jordan told me this in a phone call earlier this year when I told him about the zippers breaking on my Tactical 4.0. Apparently this was a feature only of use to a few, and since it had issues, it was removed.
- The jacket used to have two small pockets below the right and left "hand" pockets that weren't very deep and sometimes hard to open. I used to keep my gloves in those pockets but alas they are now gone. They do allow the other pockets that you normally throw your hands into to be deeper.
- There is only one key-chain holder on the jacket, in the front right pocket (unlike the tactical 4.0 that had a key chain holder in both the front right and front left - two different styles). This holder is the better of the two styles, with a retractable rubber chain.
- At least one of the deep pockets on the jacket has been removed (on my Tactical I have a deep pocket on the inside of both sides, the pocket on the right side has been removed on the Quantum). Given the fact that I once used both deep pockets to carry (on one side) a large bag of potato chips, package of cookies, and on the other side two 2 liters of soda, I guess I'll have to cut back during grocery trips!
- The fleece shows only minor changes over the 4.0 version, such as the red piping and clearview pockets.
Overall while things have changed, the core features remain the same. I'm not sure which jacket I'll end up using this winter more - the 5.0 or the 4.0 - so check in with me in the spring to see if the above changes proved to be dealbreakers.
Finally a note about sizing. Anyone who has met me in person knows I'm on the large side (some would even say Scary Large). The 4.0 series XXXLT fit me just fine, however with the removal of the tall sizes in the 5.0 line, the XXXL jacket is a bit snug (like the Evolution jacket that I reviewed last October). The 5.0 fleece fits just like the 4.0 did. While I could wear the 4.0 Fleece and Tactical Jacket at the same time, I doubt I'd be able to do that with the 5.0 series. Then again they were not meant to go together like their predecessor, so I doubt many will try to do this (e.g. the 5.0 fleece does not zip into the 5.0 jacket). If you're a "big" man wondering how you may compare to me and if the XXXL will be big enough, feel free to drop me an e-mail with any questions if you'd like to be discrete and not post them here.